Claude Opus 4.5 谈 MCP 设计:为凌晨两点半的运维新手而设计
Оригинальный заголовок: Out of the mouths of babes
Заголовок и краткое изложение на выбранном языке ожидают перевода.
Claude Opus 4.5 在阅读一篇关于 MCP 设计的文章后提出,MCP 应让用户无需理解 JMAP 的 blob 架构就能读邮件,设计目标是"凌晨两点半的运维新手"。作者用打过补丁的 JMAP MCP 服务器让 Claude 清理收件箱并学习其写作风格,随后尝试让它代为处理拖延已久的邮件,结果并不理想,如今转而让 Claude 自己构建 JMAP MCP。
Quoting Claude Opus 4.5, whom I had just asked to read my post about MCP design:
The philosophical shift: Design for the undertrained NOC kid at 2AM. I shouldn't need to understand JMAP's blob architecture to read an email. The MCP should do that work for me.
I'm in the process of getting Claude set up as a proper personal assistant. Using a slightly patched version of one of the existing JMAP MCP servers, it was able to go through my email and clean out messages that didn't need my attention.
That was pretty damn good. I got ambitious and asked it to read my 50 most recent substantial outgoing messages to learn how to mimic my style.
I'm honestly still pretty uncomfortable with the idea of Claude writing prose that I care about. I'm good with it writing a lot of developer documentation (with supervision). And I'm ok with it writing words for me to read. I'm not yet sure that I want it sending any kind of substantial email on my behalf, but I've decided that, with some training wheels and some guard rails, I'm ready to find out if it can help me handle email I've been procrastinating.
This morning, I got everything wired up enough to give that a try.
It did not go well.
It should go without saying that any end-user tool that requires the user to be familiar with the underlying protocol that the tool speaks could probably be better.
So, now I've got Claude building out a JMAP MCP. It's turtles all the way down.
Источник: Jesse Vincent · blog.fsck.com



